DMovies - Your platform for thought-provoking cinema

The Seagull

Star-studded Hollywood take on Chekhov's classical play relies on sterling performances, but it simply lacks the "dirty factor" - in cinemas Friday, September 7th

Given that we already have an American re-telling of Anton Chekhov’s play The Seagull in the 2014 Christian Camargo Film Days and Nights, I am not entirely sure why we need another American version of this story. Granted The Seagull directed by Michael Mayer is set in a not dissimilar time period as Chekhov’s original play and uses a large proportion of his original dialogue. However, I can see no other reason why every character has a US accent even though they are discussing trips to Moscow. There are samovars and serfs aplenty but still we do not believe we are in Russia, or in fact America.

We appear to be in a strange quasi romantic idyll where the nature of the life of an artist is to be discussed at length and the main players are all in love with a person other than the one who is in love with them. Days and Nights fully explores the jealousy and longing while giving us a full blooded mix of comedy and tragedy. Chekhov’s plays are after all purported to be funny when seen in their native language. This film is neither funny, not essentially tragic.

It is sad that Masha (Elizabeth Moss) is in love with Konstantin (Billy Howle) and despises school teacher Mikhail (Michael Zegen). Irina’s (Anette Benning) jealousy of Nina (Saoirse Ronan) when her lover Boris (Corey Still) falls for the teenage aspiring actress is inevitable and played to perfection by Benning. Konstantin is jealous of both Boris’s talent and Nina’s infatuation with Boris, shooting a seagull and placing it at Nina’s feet. The seagull of course is a premonition of how Boris will later destroy this young girl’s life by picking her up and putting her down again, disrespecting her ambition and sense of self in the process.

Masha’s gloom and open alcohol consumption are perfectly pitched by Elizabeth Moss (pictured below), but all of the main players in the story have essentially, what we now often site as “First World Problems”. They are for the main part, spoilt and privileged showing almost no recognition or concern for the people who work for them. Mayer places them in the background grafting away at farm and estate work and supplying food and drink indoors and outdoors to their supposed ‘betters’ as they sit and argue about which of them is more talented, younger or productive in life.

There is a beautifully telling moment as Irina leaves for Moscow when she turns to the housekeeper and a group of servants saying “Remember me fondly. Here is a rouble for the three of you”. Yes, tragedy occurs, Konstantin’s mother cares more about her acting career and her love life than she does about her son. Part way through the story she returns to work days after her son has attempted to shoot himself. Konstantin’s meagre success while she is away is discounted by his mother and she declares she has not read any of his stories “Where is the time?” There is time for ‘Lotto’, this is the image that begins and ends the film, a group of upper middle class people playing lotto in a well appointed drawing room. The film asks us to care about the emotional journey of this group, their family relationships and their growth as artists. I can’t help feeling that a few days of manual labour might have made them all appreciate their circumstances and love lives better.

Overall, this is a squeaky clean film. Bar the superb performances, it lacks the “dirty factor”.

The Seagull is out in cinemas across the UK in September, 2018.

By Fiona Whitelaw - 01-09-2018

Fiona’s driving force as a writer is to tell stories that have not been heard with the voices of those not usually listened to. Her work for screen and stage spans a variety of genres. Her latest f...

DMovies Poll

Are the Oscars dirty enough for DMovies?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Most Read

Forget Friday the 13th, Paranormal Activity and the [Read More...]
Just a few years back, finding a film [Read More...]
A lot of British people would rather forget [Read More...]
Sexual diversity is at the very heart of [Read More...]
Pigs might fly. And so Brexit might happen. [Read More...]
Films quotes are very powerful not just because [Read More...]

Read More


Aleksei German Jr

Victor Fraga - 17-02-2018

Biopic of Russian writer offers insight into a Soviet Union suffocated by censorship, plus it has plenty of anecdotes and bite-size treats for literature lovers and a convincing photography by Polish DOP Luykasz Zal (of Ida) - from the BFI London Film Festival [Read More...]

Olmo and The Seagull (Olmo e a Gaivota)

Petra Costa/ Lea Glob

Maysa Monção - 12-07-2016

Does being a mother make you a better person? This hybrid and very international doc-fiction examines the impact of maternity on a woman's personal life and work, with Chekhov's 'The Seagull' as the backdrop [Read More...]


Eduardo Coutinho

Maysa Moncao - 23-02-2016

Blending documentary, theatre and literature into one large and broad tropical melting pot [Read More...]

Facebook Comment

Website Comments

One thought on “The Seagull

  1. You do understand the basic concept of translation, right? Or do you expect the actors to speak like Boris and Natasha?

    This is mostly very bad Chekhov —gloomy and humorless, despite the satire in the original — but it somehow led you, blindly and unwittingly, into THE EXACT POINT CHEKHOV IS MAKING: that these people are wasting their lives and should be doing something, -anything-, to work for the betterment of society. As badly as Mayer and Haram have served Chekhov, this review is laughably worse in its inability to comprehend the material.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *