DMovies - Your platform for thought-provoking cinema

To a Land Unknown

Transactional human beings and accidental places: Palestinian refugees resort to a life of crime in order to survive and be reunited with their loved ones in Europe - in cinemas on Friday, February 14th

Chatila (Mahmood Bakri) and Reda (Aram Sabbah) are in two Palestinian refugees their early 20s, living in a densely populated refugee squat somewhere in the Greek capital. They are prepared to steal a woman’s purse or the local shoe store in order to raise €5 or €10 for their next meal. Their body too is readily available, with the two males ready to have sex with male clients in exchange for a meagre two-digit sum. The young Tatiana hopes to lure Chatila into her flat with the mere lure of a beer. She is very disapponited to find out that he doesn’t drink. These are transactional human beings. Their unwilling Greek hosts have thoroughly dehumanised and objectified them.

Greece is an accidental place. Chatila and Reda seek to reach Germany, where their loved ones have already settled. Thirteen-year-old Malik (Mohammad Alsurafa) ended up in the Balkans by accident: his aunt paid for him to reach Italy, but the smugglers dumped him in Athens instead. She is still fighting to be reunited with her young teenage yet very streetwise relative, but she refuses to pay upfront for his journey lest unscrupulous traffickers take him to the wrong destination yet again. Then Chatila comes up with a cunning plan, which could land Malik safely in Italy, plus earn them enough cash to finance their fake passports and dangerous journey to Germany. The operation involve a hesitant Tatiana posing as Malik’s mother.

In the second half of this 105-minute film, Chatila and Reda scramble to find out whether their ploy was successful. And they come up with yet another artful (and barely comprehensible) plan in order to raise the movie, while also vouching for Malik’s wellbeing. What started out as a humanistic movie occasionally slips into disjointed intrigue, with some clunky torture and violence elements. The destiny of several characters is left open and many questions remain intentionally unanswered. Ultimately, the excess of open ends have a negative impact on the movie’s ability to engage and enrapture.

The first message that To a Land Unknown conveys is that the profound dehumanisation and degradation of Palestinians not only leaves them vulnerable, but turns good people into apparent degenerates. Danish-Palestinian director Mahdi Fleifel (who also co-wrote the movie script, alongside Fyzal Boulifa and Jason McColgan) does this didactic determination. Chatila and Reda are prepared to put other Palestinian refugees just like them through the wringer in order to achieve their objectives. The filmmaker attempts to balance this by repeatedly demonstrating that the two young men carry out their despicable actions with regret and empathy for the victims. Reda questions whether they should return €5 to the woman who they robbed in case she needs to buy medication, and both suffer with moral injury as they inflict pain on people of their nationality.

Secondly, the movie wishes to demonstrate the complexity of the Palestinian diaspora. The aptly named co-production company Nakba FilmWorks leaves little doubt as to such intention. People are forced to leave their home in favour of a foreign continent, language and culture. The director’s family aimed for Sweden, and ended up in Denmark. He was partly raised in the Ain al-Hilweh refugee camp in Lebanon, and names his protagonist Chatila after a Palestinian settlement in Southern Beirut. The characters in a To a Land Known too have little clue as to where they may end up, just like the film title suggests. Fleifel makes it abundantly clear that the fate of Palestinians – real-life and fiction – is as open-ended as his movie’s final denouement.

To a Land Unknown showed in the Official Competition of the 2nd Mediterrane Film Festival (in Malta), when this piece was originally written. Also showing in the 4th Red Sea International Film Festival. The UK premiere takes place in October, during the 68th BFI London Film Festival. In cinemas on Friday, February 14th.


By Victor Fraga - 28-06-2024

Victor Fraga is a Brazilian born and London-based journalist and filmmaker with more than 20 years of involvement in the cinema industry and beyond. He is an LGBT writer, and describes himself as a di...

DMovies Poll

Are the Oscars dirty enough for DMovies?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Most Read

Sexual diversity is at the very heart of [Read More...]
Just a few years back, finding a film [Read More...]
Forget Friday the 13th, Paranormal Activity and the [Read More...]
A lot of British people would rather forget [Read More...]
Pigs might fly. And so Brexit might happen. [Read More...]
Films quotes are very powerful not just because [Read More...]

Read More

Silent Observers

Eliza Petkova
2025

Nairon Santos de Morais - 29-03-2025

Bulgarian director places the domesticated animals of a moribund village at the forefront, revealing that their owners's devotion isn't entirely selfless - from CPH:DOX [Read More...]

The Ban

Roisin Agnew
2025

Victor Fraga - 29-03-2025

Margaret Thatcher finds a peculiar way to silence the Republican voices of Northern Ireland, in one of the most bizarre gestures of censorship in history - from CPH:DOX [Read More...]

Seen Unseen: An Anthology of (Auto)Censorship

Firat Yucel, Erhan Örs, Sibil Çekmen, Serra Akcan, Nadir Sönmez, Hakan Bozyurt, Can Memiş, Belit sağ
2025

Victor Fraga - 29-03-2025

Eight Turkish filmmakers study the dirty machinations of censorship, raising questions about state repression and voluntary suppression - from CPH DOX [Read More...]