DMovies - Your platform for thought-provoking cinema
Audacious Brazilian film examines queerness at old age with a tender and empathetic tone, while also revealing that solitude is powerful venting outlet - from BFI Flare

This is a candid, fascinating and at times disturbing look into the life of a lonely, older and marginalised gay man. Greta tells the story of 70-year-old male nurse Pedro (Marco Nanini), who works in an overcrowded public hospital in the Northeastern city of Fortaleza. His transsexual friend Daniela (played by cis actress Denise Weinberg) suffers from kidney failure and cannot find a hospital bed. So Pedro secretly takes a wounded young man (Demick Lopes) into his own home in order to vacate a hospital space for his ailing friend.

The young man turns out to be a criminal who viciously murdered another man with 41 stabs. Despite the horrific revelation, the age gap, and the fact that both men are now in trouble with the police, they develop a tender and sexual relationship. The man refuses to budge from Pedro’s modest dwellings. And soon Pedro – who prefers being called Greta in his intimacy – is attached to the mysterious stranger, too. Meanwhile, Daniela refuses hospital treatment, despite knowing that her condition is very grave and she could be facing her very final days.

The final third of the movie consists of a jaunt into Fortaleza’s LGBT world. There is a very explicit oral sex scene in a sauna/ sex joint. Daniela delivers a classic Brazilian song on stage in a cabaret club. Pedro sits in a bar while a gogo dancer performs in the background. This is bleak and yet moving representation of an impoverished and marginalised segment of Brazilian society. Solitude is also a central topic. Pedro cries out line: “I want to be alone”, in reference to Greta Garbo’s famous phrase. Despite enjoying his time with the murderous stranger, the lonely man struggles to adapt to a life of companionship.

This is a very audacious film in its representation of queerness at old age. Marco Nanini is an iconic television actor at the age of 70. The nudity and some of the sex are very graphic. Nanini does not perform penetration and fellatio, but does appear with an erection and very much “hands on”. The portrayal of the marginalised LGBT community of Fortaleza is equally graphic and honest.

Yet this is not a perfect movie. There are a few teething problems, not entirely unusual for a first-time director. Firstly, there are a few loose ends (for example, it’s never entirely clear how the murderer repeatedly leaves and returns to Pedro’s apartment). Demick is not very convincing a manipulative murderer. And he chemistry between Nanini and Demick isn’t very good. As a result, some of the sex sequences don’t seem very authentic, and some of the dialogues a little contrived. And the ending of the movie is a bit clumsy. Nanini, on the other hand, is nothing short of spectacular.

The Brazilian LGBT community has been consistently berated by Brazil’s fascist president Jair Bolsonaro. He removed LGBT rights from the Human Rights statute in his second day in office his year, and he has consistently and unequivocally insulted the LGBT community. He shouted profanities at the only member LGBT member of parliament Jean Wyllys, and he clarified that he would prefer a dead child to a gay son. Jean Wyllys left the country a few weeks ago in self-exile following repeated death threats. Bolsonaro openly celebrated his departure on Twitter, calling the occasion “a great day for Brazil”. The importance of progressive and liberating films like Greta therefore cannot be overstated.

Greta showed in the 69th Berlin International Film Festival in February 2019, when this piece was originally written. It premieres in the UK as part of BFI Flare (March 21st to the 31st).


By Victor Fraga - 14-02-2019

Victor Fraga is a Brazilian born and London-based journalist and filmmaker with more than 20 years of involvement in the cinema industry and beyond. He is an LGBT writer, and describes himself as a di...

DMovies Poll

Are the Oscars dirty enough for DMovies?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Most Read

Sexual diversity is at the very heart of [Read More...]
Just a few years back, finding a film [Read More...]
Forget Friday the 13th, Paranormal Activity and the [Read More...]
A lot of British people would rather forget [Read More...]
Pigs might fly. And so Brexit might happen. [Read More...]
QUICK AND DIRTY: LIVE FROM TALLINN A candidate’s [Read More...]

Read More

Tranny Fag (Bixa Travesty)

Kiko Goifman and Claudia Priscilla
2018

Victor Fraga - 20-02-2018

Are you man enough for me? Brazilian gender terrorist Linn da Quebrada is in Europe in order to savage your primitive notions of masculinity and femininity - in London on Friday, June 15th [Read More...]

Hard Paint (Tinta Bruta)

Marcio Reolon and Filipe Matzembacher
2018

Victor Fraga - 19-02-2018

All the colours of the rainbow! Brazilian queer film about young man earning a living as a sexy glow paint performer in chat rooms avoids cliches, is psychologically multilayered and surprisingly moving - in cinemas Friday, August 2nd [Read More...]

Futuro Beach (Praia do Futuro)

Karim Ainouz
2015

Victor Fraga - 30-01-2016

Immigration to Europe leads gay lifeguard to a violent rupture with Brazil, in the latest film by Brazilian veteran Karim Ainouz [Read More...]