DMovies - Your platform for thought-provoking cinema

Trans Memoria

Thailand is the setting for a journey of reflection, identity, and pain in a deeply emotional documentary - from 58th Karlovy Vary International Film, Festival

QUICK AND DIRTY: LIVE FROM KARLOVY VARY

Painful subject matter is given a personal perspective in this documentary about returning to the past. Mostly filmed in 2019, Swedish writer and director Victoria Verseau chronicles her return to Thailand where, in 2012, she underwent gender-affirming surgery. She comes to the country mourning her friend Meril, a French woman whom she made friends with during surgery, before taking her life in 2015. She comes with two other transitioning women, Athena and Aamina, initially intending for them to play her and Meril in reconstructions, before they become companions in this excavation of her pain.

To call this solely a film about transition would be too simple, although there are many aspects that will feel unique to the Trans or Queer experience. Victoria shows brief glimpses of her operation, before and after, as well as latter footage of her still debating as to how she feels about it. While she is unequivocal about making the right choice, there is a sense of disappointment that this hard-fought victory didn’t solve everything for her. Through conversations with Athena and Aamina, we look at the hard choices that come with the journey trans people take, and the darker side of this struggle. Each woman alludes to suicide as a possibility in their lives, something that is reflected in the high number of suicide attempts among Trans youth. It’s likely many viewers in the community with have their own Meril, and that pain is in some ways cathartic.

It’s clear Verseau has a bleak perspective on life, remarking “our dreams were life threatening. Hope is a dangerous thing for women like us”. It’s all entirely valid, although clearly told from someone still reeling from loss. In that sense, this is the also the story of a grieving friend, searching for small aspects of the first person she met in a similar situation. We see her searching Meril’s old apartment for any shred of recollection from neighbours, and a sad phone call to Meril’s family friend, playing out while the camera looks at mounds of discarded tablet blister packs. It’s here where the film becomes a personal journey rather than a statement about identity, and Verseau gets lost in her own investigation.

Luckily, her companions are on hand to question her, particularly Athena whose blunt retorts seem to change the direction of the film. As Verseau seems to be sinking further into her own sadness, justifying it as showing the darkness and light of the Trans experience, Athena replies “where is the light here?” Verseau never quite answers that, suggesting that perhaps being alive is hopeful in itself. Nevertheless, there are touching moments of sisterhood between the women, all of whom have their own stories and scars, and an ending that seems to point to a brighter future for all involved.

This film is not for the squeamish, featuring many closeups of medical procedures. However, Victoria Verseau’s work is a reminder that there is a prism of emotions that are part of transition, many of which are relatable to anyone. You leave the film hoping all involved find what they’re looking for, and hoping that path of future generations won’t be so difficult.

Trans Memoria just premiered in the 58th Karlovy Vary International Fil, Festival.


By Victoria Luxford - 01-07-2024

London-born Victoria Luxford has been a film critic and broadcaster since 2007, writing about cinema all over the world. Beginning with regional magazines and entertainment websites, she soon built up...

DMovies Poll

Are the Oscars dirty enough for DMovies?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Most Read

Forget Friday the 13th, Paranormal Activity and the [Read More...]
Just a few years back, finding a film [Read More...]
A lot of British people would rather forget [Read More...]
Sexual diversity is at the very heart of [Read More...]
Pigs might fly. And so Brexit might happen. [Read More...]
Films quotes are very powerful not just because [Read More...]

Read More

A long hard road of grit and glee

 

Lobo Pasolini - 10-07-2024

As Queen Priscilla turns 30, Lobo Pasolini looks back at the queer classic that combined comedy, splendour and tragedy, and changed the history of cinema [Read More...]

Game for lovers of genre cinema

 

Mariano Garcia - 10-07-2024

Mariano Garcia investigates the connection between genre film and genre games, while also revealing the most important creations in each category [Read More...]

No film lovers on their underwear: our verdict of the 58th edition of Karlovy Vary

 

Victor Fraga - 08-07-2024

For the first time, DMovies' editor Victor Fraga attends the Karlovy Vary International Film Festival, the last one of the large European festivals on his list; these are the winners, our dirty picks, and impressions [Read More...]